We’ve all been there: driving past a new shopping center or a renovated plaza, and the first thing that catches our eye is a sleek new monument sign, proudly displaying the names of the businesses inside. Or maybe we’re considering a new location, and the prime spot has a massive pylon sign visible from the main road. These signs aren't just decorations; they're critical for getting customers through our doors. But what happens when we're already mid-lease, or approaching a renewal, and suddenly these opportunities emerge, or worse, are already locked down by our competitors? That's when we need to understand our signage rights, and as a recent piece from Hollander Real Estate Law reminds us, getting these sorted out early can save a lot of headaches later.
Why Signage Rights Matter Early
The Hollander Real Estate Law article really drives home the point that signage rights aren't something to gloss over. They emphasize that negotiating these rights should be a priority from the very beginning of a commercial lease negotiation. This isn't just about the sign above our storefront, either. The authors specifically call out future structures like monument or pylon signs that might not even exist when we first sign our lease. Imagine signing a five-year lease, and three years in, the landlord decides to build a new pylon sign on the property that would be perfect for our business. If we didn't negotiate for a spot on that sign upfront, we might find ourselves out of luck, or paying a premium we could have avoided. They stress that securing these rights early can prevent future disputes and ensure our business gets the visibility it needs.
Practical Implications for Tenants
So, what does this mean for us, the independent retailers and small business owners navigating these leases? It means looking beyond the immediate storefront. When reviewing a lease, we need to actively seek out clauses related to "Signage Rights," "Pylon Signage," "Monument Signage," or even "Visibility Easements." A common trap is a lease that vaguely states the landlord "reserves the right to install signage as they deem appropriate." This might sound innocuous, but it gives the landlord carte blanche to put up signs that benefit other tenants, or to charge us exorbitant fees for a spot we assumed would be included. We've seen situations where a new tenant moves in, gets a prominent spot on a newly installed pylon sign, and our existing business, which has been there for years, is relegated to a tiny panel or even overlooked entirely.
A reasonable negotiating position involves not just asking for a spot, but specifying the type, size, and location of our signage. This includes our storefront signage, but crucially, also any common area signage like monument or pylon signs. We should aim to define our entitlement to a panel on any existing or future common area signs, specifying the size of that panel, its location (e.g., "top panel," "eye-level panel"), and the cost, if any. Sometimes, a landlord will include signage rights as part of the base rent, while others will charge an additional "signage fee" or pass through costs as part of Common Area Maintenance (CAM). Understanding these financial implications upfront can prevent unwelcome surprises on our monthly statements. If a pylon sign is built later, and we didn't secure our rights, we might face a significant additional charge, potentially thousands of dollars annually, for a space that would have been free or deeply discounted if negotiated early.
What to Check This Week
Take a look at your current lease agreement, especially if a renewal is coming up or if you've noticed new signage going up in your center. Find the section on "Signage" or "Exterior Signage" and see what it says about common area signs like pylons or monuments. If it's vague or silent, that's a red flag. If you're negotiating a new lease, make sure to explicitly include language that guarantees your business a specific panel on any existing or future common area signage, detailing the size, location, and associated costs. Don't assume anything will be offered or included later. This community is full of shared experiences, so feel free to share what you find or what you've successfully negotiated in the forum.